Russell Simmons' Solutions
After the Don Imus firing over making “ho” jokes at the
Simmons is one of a relatively new species in the American entertainment industry: the “rap mogul.” A co-founder of the Def Jam rap label way back in 1984, Simmons was an early pioneer in taking this spoken-word genre – one cannot call it “music” – from the streets right into the American radio mainstream. Def Jam Records has a sorry history promoting vile gangsta-rap messages, but now Simmons is having serious second thoughts. He's proclaiming loudly and most eloquently that the street poets need to drop some words from that mainstream repertoire – the N-word, “bitch,” and “ho.” These need to be considered extreme curse words, he says, and should be taken off the public airwaves, just like the famous “seven nasty words” that are banned, for the simple reason that children are in the audience. To be sure, some radio stations regularly edit such language, but many others don't.
He doesn't advocate dropping this language altogether, which is unfortunate. Simmons concedes that millions of adults listen to unexpurgated rap CDs, and is unwilling to condemn it. Still, the move to take this off mainstream radio is a significant start. On “The O'Reilly Factor,” Simmons declared, “I think that children, and parents, and everyone else who doesn't really understand the hip-hop community should have a choice....we want people to choose what they want. And if you turn on mainstream radio, you shouldn't have to hear these words.”
Simmons has issued a statement from his Hip Hop Summit Action Network recommending the music industry get serious and form a voluntary Coalition on Broadcast Standards, consisting of leading executives from music, radio and TV industries. This coalition would recommend guidelines for lyrical and visual standards within the industries. He also recommended that the recording industry establish artist mentoring programs and forums to stimulate effective dialogue between artists, hip-hop fans, industry leaders and others to promote “better understanding and positive change.”
These actions are not making him popular in rap circles. But there are many blacks – especially black women – cheering him on for joining their long-standing opposition.
This was a big moment. Prior to this announcement Simmons was clearly uneasy and sounded almost schizophrenic, vigorously defending the rappers' right to use the insulting words while simultaneously protesting them, calling them “misogynistic” and “racist.” When he appeared on the Oprah Winfrey show last month, he argued the problem was larger than the music world: “Whether it's our sexism, our racism, our homophobia, or our violence, the hip-hop community sometimes can be a good mirror of our dirt and sometimes the dirt that we try to cover up.” Still, by the end of the show Simmons agreed that rappers had a problem with obscene lyrics.
Defenders of nasty rap songs often make that argument that the nastiness merely reflects on society. The excuse-makers at the rap magazine Vibe now are arguing that the new sensitivity to language is some sort of a conspiracy to silence political speech. “The desire to police hip hop at the level of language does little to address the sexism, misogyny and homophobia that informs the treatment of black women in black communities and the larger society.”
That's bunk. Black women are being devalued and denigrated not primarily by “society” but primarily by destructive elements within the black community itself. That segment of the black community must learn to shower more love on its own mothers, its own sisters, and its own daughters before it has the audacity to cast the first stone at any other segment of the larger society. If other races can be charged with never being able to understand the historic pain of the black experience, then rappers should be the first to bring the healing, not the first to inflict the pain.
People trying to raise their children to have more respect for women than the “ho” culture provides are not buying the “mirror of our dirt” analogy. When a person gets up in the morning, the mirror reflects that they look groggy and unkempt. No one hails or blames the mirror for this image. It is high time the rap community clean up its act. Russell Simmons should be hailed for daring to suggest rappers (and their moguls) groom their language, and leave their linguistic bad breath at home.
L. Brent Bozell is the founder of the Media Research Center.